England’s version of March Madness got into full swing this weekend with the 3rd round of the FA Cup now in the books. There have already been a number of upsets and there are at least 2 clubs who will believe that they’re going on a Cinderella-run of sorts. A more in-depth review can be found below!
Manchester United’s particular 3rd round tie was against Aston Villa at Old Trafford, held earlier on today. Aston Villa are currently in the bottom half of the Premier League table, but they are an intriguing side nonetheless given that their manager is none other than former Liverpool player (and villain of Old Trafford) Steven Gerrard. He was easily their best player for most of his career, and he certainly caused one or two anxious affairs for United when he was on the pitch in midfield. I was hoping the lads would be up for this one given who the opposite manager is, as there is nothing Gerrard (and Liverpool) would like more than to knock United out of a major tournament.
But this was once again a lackluster affair from United. They did get the game’s only goal on 8 minutes via a header from Scott McTominay, but the victory tends to paper over the cracks of all the issues on display. Villa were the better side for most the game, in particular the second half. They even had the ball in the net twice, but both goals were correctly ruled out after VAR review. Raphael Varane was solid in central defense and David De Gea had a good day in goal, but make no mistake, this was an ugly match. Marcus Rashford looks like a shadow of himself. Mason Greenwood is developing some ball-hogging tendencies that usually result in him losing possession. Further, we can’t retain possession to save our lives as collective team. It’s the same problem that has haunted us for over a month now – we give the ball away far too easily and there’s no effort (or at least no coordinated effort) to win it back.
There is still some adjustment to manager Ralf Rangnick’s playing style going on, and I am not sure how much this particular squad has bought into it. To be fair, there is a question of whether playing with only two men in midfield is an effective strategy for United and that is something that needs to be addressed more in-depth as the season moves forward. However, the lack of effort in ball recovery is perhaps an indication that not everyone fulling co-signs to this new style of play. That is not good at all, for several reasons. For one, in football you have to play as a unit. If multiple players don’t want to play the tactics that the rest of the team is doing, it’s not going to work. For two, it speaks to a level of apathy that is unacceptable for professional athletes. They all get paid millions to play a kids game, and that seems to have been somewhat forgotten.
I also think that several of our players, most notably Rashford, are not in the right space mentally. Rashford is not aggressive enough, and Greenwood is probably too aggressive. Substitute Anthony Elanga did more on the left wing in 10 minutes than Rashford did in 80. I love Rashford and I want to see him succeed, so I’d like to see another senior member of the team or one of the coaches get with him and see what the problem is. He’s insanely talented, but he hasn’t looked the same since he returned to the club after the Euros this past summer.
In short, Rangnick needs to get this squad together. I was happy with Elanga’s energy and Varane’s discipline today, but that’s really about it. Rashford, Greenwood, Bruno Fernandes, and Edinson Cavani all need to improve. The whole squad does really, but those 4 in particular are playing well below their usual standards.
United will host Championship side Middlesbrough at Old Trafford in the next round of the FA Cup. The next fixture though is a repeat of this one – hosting Villa in the Premier League in 5 days’ time. If we play like this again against them, they will at least earn a draw or outright beat us.
***
A quick but important shoutout to three other clubs – Kidderminster Harriers FC and Boreham Wood FC. I won’t lie, I hadn’t heard of those two clubs before yesterday. But these two have made some serious waves by winning their FA Cup 3rd Round fixtures – by beating Reading FC and AFC Wimbledon respectively. What makes those two results so notable is that both Kidderminster and Boreham Wood are non-league teams, meaning they are comprised entirely of semi-professional players. There are 8 divisions in the English football pyramid, and both teams play in the 6th division, referred to as the National League. It’s always great to see the minnows earn a chance to swim with the big fish, which is exactly what these two have done. For their efforts, Kidderminster get the reward of hosting Premier League side West Ham United, while Boreham Wood will travel to play Championship side AFC Bournemouth. Both clubs stand to make a good deal of money from these fixtures, and for me there’s nothing cooler than semi-pros getting to try their hand against professional millionaires. Imagine you and 5 friends start a basketball team, and your get far enough into a tournament to get a chance at playing the LA Lakers or Chicago Bulls. That’s the equivalent of what is happening here.
Also a very special shoutout to Nottingham Forest FC, a Championship side who knocked Arsenal out of the FA Cup yesterday at Emirates Stadium. Forest is my grandparents’ club and I have taken a tour of that club’s stadium personally, so I feel a special affinity towards them when they aren’t playing United. It’s a big achievement for Forest to take down one of the giants, and it was in no small part thanks to James Garner (no relation to the actor), a midfielder on loan to Forest from United. Forest have been devoid of major success for a few decades now so it’s great to see them get a result. Always good to see Arsenal lose in the FA Cup as well, as they have won it more times than any other club.