FA Cup: Manchester United Shock Liverpool in Quarterfinal Classic

There’s no denying that this hasn’t been a good season by the illustrious standards of Manchester United. They won’t be winning the Premier League, the top-4 seems like it will take a borderline miracle to attain, they lost their League Cup crown earlier in the season, and they are out of all European competitions. They’ve been incredibly inconsistent all year, with injuries playing a massive role in their sputtering form. The Red Devils’ last realistic chance at any trophy this season is in the illustrious FA Cup – the oldest single-elimination football tournament in the world. United squeaked by Nottingham Forest at the City Ground 1-0 in the 5th round, which set up an incredibly juicy quarterfinals tie with their hated rivals Liverpool earlier today at Old Trafford. While these two sides have their own rich histories and traditions of winning, title-contenders Liverpool were the heavy favorites to move on to the semifinals at Wembley Stadium.

But under-fire United manager Erik ten Hag and the squad had other plans. United were the dominant team for the first 10 minutes or so, and cashed in on their dominance thanks a rebound finish from midfielder Scott McTominay. They couldn’t add another one in the first half though, and Liverpool struck back twice at the end of the first half via midfielders Alexis Mac Allister and winger/forward Mohamed Salah. United scored via winger Antony dos Santos (playing at left back today) on 87 minutes though, which forced extra time at 2-2. Liverpool then went ahead again on 105 minutes via attacking midfielder Harvey Elliot, only for United to continue to fight back and get a 3rd from winger/forward Marcus Rashford. Finally, in the dying seconds of stoppage time and after a breathless 120 minutes of football, United winger Amad Diallo found the opposite corner with a low finish after a breakaway. Old Trafford erupted in joy as the ball rolled past Scousers keeper Caoimhin Kelleher for 4-3. Diallo ended up being sent off on a second yellow card for removing his shirt during the goal celebration, but it was an absolutely legendary 30ish minute cameo from the Ivorian winger.

I blitzed through the goals and major incidents recap mostly because there are so many other talking points to discuss. For one, ETH may have saved his job next season with this performance. I have long been a defender of ETH because I generally believe his footballing philosophy is one that can win matches, but it was becoming more and more difficult to defend him with each head-scratching lineup or substitution. But today, he got it 100% right. It was extremely unorthodox at times, with numerous players playing out of position and we didn’t seem to have a midfield late on in the match, but it somehow worked. I could have sworn I saw us in a 4-1-5 formation at some point! I also saw Antony at left back, Bruno Fernandes in central defense, and Harry Maguire was effectively a striker! It was ludicrous, but again, it worked. Bringing on Diallo and Antony ended up being brilliant moves as well. It was chaos ball, but maybe some chaos is just what was needed to make the Scousers uncomfortable.

But moreover, I think the big headline from today is not about ETH, nor is it about United beating their biggest rival in a classic football match. The biggest takeaway from today from the perspective of the supporters is that the Red Devils finally showed some fight. They kept trying to win the match and never stopped, and it paid off big time. Far too often this season and last, this has looked like a team that lacked a competitive spirit. Every once in a while they show some spine, but more often than not United have repeatedly shown a lack of backbone in bigger matches once they get punched in the face. Even with a lead, if they concede a cheap goal or a call from the referee doesn’t go their way, they have often just capitulated and lacked a desire to carry on fighting. That did not happen today, however. Indeed, it was just the opposite. They got a somewhat surprising lead, but conceded two very cheap goals just before halftime. It was sadly expected by many (including me) that they would yet again surrender and not really try in the second half. But they came out with dogged determination, Liverpool were a bit sloppy with some of their chances, and they got an equalizer late on to force extra time. They could have easily capitulated again when Liverpool went ahead 3-2 on 105 minutes, but they just kept running forward and getting the ball ahead to the attacking players. Again, it paid off when Rashford made it 3-3. That put them in a position to go and win it, and they took advantage of some questionable tactics by Liverpool manager Jurgen Klopp to go and win the match.

Brilliant match today. Absolutely brilliant. Likely the best one during the ETH regime. To beat our biggest rival in the FA Cup quarterfinals as underdogs in the dying seconds of extra time is the stuff dreams are made of. Excellent matches from Rashford, Bruno, McTominay, Maguire, Diallo, midfielder Kobbie Mainoo, winger/forward Alejandro Garnacho, and Antony. Some special recognition to right back (left back?) Diogo Dalot as well, who did not put a foot wrong for 120 minutes. When this team believes in themselves, they have the ability to beat some of the best teams in Europe. Well done to the home supporters at Old Trafford too, who were raucous from start to finish.

It’s true this season has not gone well. It’s true that inconsistency and injuries have plagued the Red Devils all year. It’s true that we are still at the beginning of a massive overhaul that will continue for several more seasons. Today made all of that much easier to digest, though. I believe this will show both the Glazers and new owner Sir Jim Ratcliffe that ETH is the man to guide us through this rebuild and get us back the promised land. All of the problems surrounding the club can be temporarily forgotten, because today we knocked the Scousers out of the FA Cup. Hope the lads get some good celebrating in tonight.

United have been drawn against Championship side Coventry City in the semifinals of the FA Cup, to be played in about a month’s time at Wembley. They have some difficult matches to be played in the Premier League between now and then, but all eyes are now on the weekend of April 20/21. The top 4 would still be a great achievement given how this season has gone, but honestly, if I had to choose, I’d want us to go and win the FA Cup. Let’s turn this crap season into something positive by finishing strongly with a trophy. Manchester City take on Chelsea in the other half of the semifinal.

Glory Glory Man United! Glazers Out!

Premier League – Another Away Defeat, This Time in Nottingham

Manchester United traveled to the East Midlands of England earlier today for a Premier League match against Nottingham Forest at the City Ground. United were looking to continue their winning momentum having beaten Aston Villa at Old Trafford on Boxing Day, while Forest were also looking to continue their winning form under new manager Nuno Espirito Santo. For a team like Forest in a relegation battle, every point they can scrape matters. The points mattered for United and manager Erik ten Hag as well, but for the visitors it was more about putting in a competent performance and playing with the consistency that has eluded them this season.

The atmosphere inside the City Ground was electric and high energy from the start, although the play on the pitch in the first half from both sides was decidedly dull. Forest were probably slightly better on the balance of things, mainly because United were absolutely anemic in attack. They put together some decent moves towards the end of the half, but the shots on goal were few and far between. Forest failed to score as well, but they looked much more cohesive when in possession. For the umpteenth time this season, United looked clueless in attack. A key substitution was made at halftime by ETH, with defensive midfielder Kobbie Mainoo being replaced by fellow midfielder Scott McTominay. More on this substitution below.

The second half was much more high-energy and uptempo from both sides. Forest grew into the game considerably well, likely buoyed by their home support. The opening goal came from midfielder Nicolas Dominguez, who slotted home past United keeper Andre Onana on the hour mark. Hard to say Forest didn’t deserve it, but the defending from United was very poor. As a defensive midfielder, McTominay was responsible for defending the edge of the box. For whatever reason though, he wasn’t there and Dominguez was given an opening from which to shoot. Onana maybe could have done better with his positioning, but McTominay has to be in position to make a clearance in situations like this one.

I was resigned to another away defeat for United given their lack of urgency going forward, but the Red Devils responded a bit (finally) after going down 1-0. Left back Diogo Dalot struck the post after a good move, and United got an equalizer on 78 minutes thanks to some good pressing from winger Alejandro Garnacho and a bad mistake by Forest keeper Matt Turner. Turner had been having issues playing the ball out from the back for most of the half, and Garnacho jumped on one of his many unconvincing passes. He won the ball about 20 yards out from goal, after which he found winger/forward Marcus Rashford to his left. The Forest defense was scrambling to get back, and Rashford was able to curve a shot along the ground past Turner for 1-1. The goal came about more because of the mistake from Turner than anything else, but of course it counted all the same. I would have been more than pleased with a 1-1 given how the match had gone, as well. Well done to Rashford for finishing clinically despite not being in good scoring form this season.

Unfortunately, United’s defense was undone again just four minutes later by attacking midfielder Morgan Gibbs-White. United were pushing for a winner, but were caught out on a swift counter-attack organized by winger (and former United player) Anthony Elanga. Elanga brought the ball forward before centering it along the ground for Gibbs-White, who curled a spectacular shot around center-back Jonny Evans that crept inside Onana’s left-hand post. Again, a fine move and finish from Forest, but where was the marking from United? Evans and fellow center back Raphael Varane weren’t communicating properly, and McTominay was again nowhere to be found when he was supposed to be covering the edge of the box. Gibbs-White is a talented player, and he was given far too much room to shoot. 2-1 to Forest.

United pushed again for another equalizer and were aided by a staggering 10 minutes of stoppage time, but the best they could muster was a deflected effort from midfielder Bruno Fernandes that was saved by Turner. A few more routine saves from the American keeper helped Forest out the rest of the match, and the Garibaldi Reds 2-1 winners on the day. It was their first ever victory over United at the City Ground, and it was a crucial three points towards their survival at the end of the season. All credit to Forest and Nuno, but United were bad yet again.

Frustratingly, there was again a lack of urgency and desire from the players until they were already down 1-0. I don’t know why they don’t start trying until they’re already losing. Another big factor was ETH’s initial tactics and substitutions. He insists on playing Garnacho on the left wing, with opposite winger Antony dos Santos occupying the right wing. This is a good idea if both are encouraged to cut inside and get shots away from distance, but teams have figured out that tactic and they know how to prevent it. Antony in particular was poor today. It’s not a coincidence that United improved when he was taken off and replaced by fellow winger Amad Diallo. Antony has scored just one goal in 33 matches in 2023, and he has not justified his £85 million price tag. I don’t know why ETH simply doesn’t swap Garnacho and Antony so they can ping crosses in with their preferred foot. The “cutting inside to shoot” tactic isn’t working and hasn’t worked, so why not try something different?

Further, taking off Mainoo for McTominay was utterly baffling from ETH. Mainoo has been one of our better midfielders since breaking into the first team earlier this season, and he was doing fairly well at helping to control the midfield. So why was he taken off? There was no injury or yellow card situation for him, but ETH still elected to take him off at halftime anyway. As has been discussed before on this blog, McTominay is not a defensive midfielder. He is simply not good at it and is much more suited to attacking than the defending. It could be argued that McTominay was at fault for both Forest goals due to being out of position both times. United may still have lost anyway, but I think Mainoo would have done much better at helping the defense than McTominay did.

This is the first match where I’ve really questioned what ETH is trying to do. He needs to stop trying to make the inverted winger tactic work, and he really needs to ensure that McTominay is not playing as a defensive midfielder. Is it stubbornness from the Dutchman? Lack of options? I know the injuries have been bad this season, but I think United could have nicked a draw today had Mainoo been on the pitch longer. ETH really needs to re-evaluate his tactics, and the team selection needs further scrutiny as well. Put Antony on the left, Garnacho on the right, and stick a center forward between the two of them with Bruno in behind. Let’s get a lot more players into the box and have the wingers play crosses in to them. And at the risk of sounding like a broken record, there needs to be a lot more desire and drive from a good portion of this United team.

United remain 7th in the Premier League table, but could fall as far as 9th once Brighton and Newcastle play their games in hand tomorrow. Next up, it’s a short trip to Wigan, England for a match in the FA Cup with Wigan Athletic. The FA Cup is our last chance at a trophy this season, and ETH really needs a victory there to restore some of the supporters’ faith in him. If they lose to a lower league side in the 3rd round of the FA Cup, the seat underneath ETH will become very hot indeed.

Glazers Out!

Premier League: A Tale of Two Matches – Newcastle and Chelsea

The past two matches have seen United lose away to Newcastle 1-0, followed by a 2-1 victory over Chelsea at Old Trafford earlier today. The Red Devils looked god-awful against Newcastle at the weekend and probably should have lost by a bigger margin. In contrast, they looked borderline spectacular against Chelsea and probably should have won by more. But there were only four days between these matches, so how can a team like United look so bad in one match and then play so wonderfully in the next one? Well, there’s several reasons…

Location, Location, Location

United have been dismal away from home during the tenure of manager Erik ten Hag. No two ways about it. They haven’t beaten a top-half of the table side away from home since 2021. St. James’ Park in the northeast of England is a cold and dreary place to play, and the fans there always create a tough atmosphere. United’s away form against the big clubs is easily the toughest nut ETH has yet to crack.

At home however, United are a juggernaut. They don’t lose often within the hallowed halls of Old Trafford. Indeed, they have claimed the scalps of some of the biggest clubs in Europe when playing in front of 75,000 screaming United supporters. Old Trafford has been a fortress during ETH’s time in charge, and it’s walls held firm for the most part again today.

The Opposition

Newcastle are a better team than Chelsea, as things stand. Chelsea have tons of new signings and a manager (Mauricio Pochettino) who is still trying to figure out his best XI players. Manager Eddie Howe at Newcastle has his lads drilled exceptionally well and they have the financial backing of an oil state, which has allowed them to bring in some very talented players.

Line-Ups

ETH shuffled the deck quite a bit between the previous match and the one today, largely because he had to. Forwards Marcus Rashford and Anthony Martial have been in poor form for weeks now, with Rashford playing particularly poorly in the previous match. Those two players were dropped to the bench in favor of winger Antony dos Santos and striker Rasmus Højlund respectively. Further, midfielder Sofyan Amrabat was given a start, paired with Scott McTominay in midfield.

Højlund and Antony both had stellar games, and Amrabat put in a very good shift as well. Antony won a penalty on 8 minutes that midfielder Bruno Fernandes failed to convert, and even though Højlund has yet to open his Premier League scoring account, he was tireless in his running today and put himself about on the pitch in a way that continually caused problems for Chelsea. Amrabat had a key tackle in the buildup to McTominay’s opener on 19 minutes as well. I am really happy with how Mainoo played when he came on as a substitute. He didn’t do particularly well against Newcastle, but his pairing with Amrabat in the center of the park really seemed to suit him. Mainoo has the energy and athleticism, while Amrabat has a ton of experience playing at the highest levels. Their styles of play compliment each other well.

Effort

You would think that a team full of professional athletes wouldn’t need to be told to play hard and put in good effort. Counter-intuitively though, it seems that’s exactly what was needed. The effort on display from the players in red was easily the biggest contrast to the loss against Newcastle last weekend. The majority of the team was guilty of bad effort last weekend, but I want to talk about a single player specifically.

I don’t know what’s wrong with Rashford. He’s in the “effort” section because he showed zero of it against Newcastle, and when he came on today against Chelsea in the closing minutes, he proceeded to again show zero of it. I just don’t get it. He’s not running anywhere. He walks or jogs when running is definitely required. I know he knows this, but no one is going to be a world-class footballer if they don’t run. The media is rampant with speculation that he’s squabbling with ETH or somehow unhappy with how things are going. I don’t know if that’s true or not, but his lack of effort is totally unprofessional. It’s okay to be frustrated or upset with the manager. It’s okay to not be happy when the team is in inconsistent form. The unacceptable thing is not trying! The professional thing to do would be to go out and give 100% even if you’re frustrated, so that supporters know you’re at least trying. I am a big fan of Rashford and have been since he came up through the United youth academy, but I’m not going to defend his lack of effort anymore.

Since this post is all about contrasts, let’s contrast Rashford’s lack of effort with another maligned United player – center back Harry Maguire. This is a man who was stripped of the captaincy in the off-season, and was only seeing so much playing time this year because of injuries to fellow center backs Lisandro Martinez and Raphael Varane. I don’t think I’ve seen a player take the amount of stick that Maguire gets on social media every time he makes a mistake. It’s absolutely brutal. Maguire’s season started off extremely rough and the noise around his form was quite loud, but he kept his head down and kept himself focused on the game. He was a rock at the center of defense today, his overall play in the month of November earned him the accolade of Premier League Player of the Month, awarded to him today. Rashford should take note of how Maguire ignored all the noise around him and just focused on working hard and playing hard. Even if Martinez and Varane were suddenly fit to play, it would be hard for ETH to drop Maguire due to his excellent form. Both of them are extremely talented players, but one is displaying focus and determination right now, while the other is not.

Tactics and Execution

Interestingly, the tactics in the Newcastle match and the Chelsea match today were not all that different. ETH does not deviate much from his preferred 4-2-3-1, with the players running a counter-press when out of possession, and building from the back when in possession. In order to effectively play the counter-press, every attacking and midfield player needs to know when to press and on which opposing player. Vitally, the players must be willing to run at the opposition, and not just let them have possession without pressure. If one player doesn’t press effectively, ETH’s system is practically neutered. This is almost exactly what happened Newcastle. We had an attacking player who didn’t feel like running anywhere, and as a result we didn’t create anything for the first 80 minutes.

Højlund, Antony, Bruno, Amrabat, and winger Alejandro Garnacho all executed the tactics wonderfully today. They were coordinated in their press and Chelsea often looked rudderless at times due to it. Amrabat pressing the ball in the attacking third is what led to United’s first goal! They forced Chelsea into a turnover in a dangerous area, and United punished the Blues for it. ETH football in a nutshell. The finishing was poor today and United should have had at least 4 goals, and that has to improve, but the chance creation was so much better today. Credit to McTominay for getting both United goals. The Scotsman is in truly wonderful attacking form this season, and being given license by ETH to roam forward a bit more has suited him well.

ETH has faced some frankly ridiculous media speculation in the past four days that his job may be in jeopardy if United’s poor form continued. The media were trying to generate headlines and clicks of course, but this match should end any wild conjecture that ETH will be sacked soon or that he’s somehow lost the locker room. It’s clear he’s the man to bring us out of this mess. He knows this team is far from perfect and that there is still a ways to go before we are back at the top, but we’re headed in the right direction. He has the tactical nous for the job as has been evidenced, and it seems he has finally learned to drop players in poor form. Man-management is a criminally under-appreciated aspect of what it takes to be the manager of a multi-billion pound football club. You have to be able to manage the often very large egos of professional athletes, and it’s a skill that takes a very deft touch. There is an abundance of evidence that the overwhelming majority of the players believe in him and what he’s trying to do. The Glazers still need to sell the team and leave, but it’s clear we finally have the right manager at the helm.

Conclusion

A changed line-up, better effort, and better execution are the main reasons why United were so much better today against Chelsea than against Newcastle last week. As has been said a thousand times on this blog though, the inconsistency has to stop. I won’t be celebrating this club’s resurrection until we win the Premier League title again, and inconsistent teams do not win titles. Well done against Chelsea today, but if we have another Newcastle away-type match, it means little.

Glory Glory Man United! Glazers Out!

Champions League: A Chaotic Draw in Türkiye

Manchester United traveled to Türkiye last Wednesday for the penultimate match in their Champions League group stage campaign for a match against Galatasaray at Rams Park in Istanbul. It was a positively terrifying atmosphere, with the home support in full throat before, during, and after the match. Foreign clubs can and often do struggle in such a hostile atmosphere, which makes Turkish clubs very difficult to beat when they are at home. United needed 3 points to resuscitate a fairly dead European campaign, while Galatasaray also needed a victory to cement their claim on second place in the group.

The Red Devils got off to a flying start, getting two goals in the opening 20 minutes. Winger Alejandro Garnacho carried on his good form from the weekend and got the first with a high finish from close range, followed by midfielder Bruno Fernandes seven minutes later. Bruno picked up the ball on the left wing outside the box, then took a touch or two before unleashing a screamer of a shot from 20 yards out that Galatasaray keeper Fernando Muslera could do nothing about. The raucous crowd in Istanbul, while still loud, was the quietest it had been all evening.

The Cimbom were undeterred though. Bruno needlessly gave away a free kick in a dangerous area around the 28 minute mark, and United were punished for that recklessness by winger/forward Hakim Ziyech. He hit a low free-kick along the ground that went under the United wall and wrong-footed keeper Andre Onana. Well struck by Ziyech, but Onana likely should have done better to get down and make the save. It was 2-1 at the end of the first 45 minutes though, and United had done well to not concede another before halftime.

Midfielder Scott McTominay got a third goal for United on 55 minutes, and it was the result of well-executed build up from the back by United. After playing the ball through the middle of the pitch, winger Antony dos Santos found right back Aaron Wan-Bissaka on an overlapping run to his right. AWB delivered a beautiful cross into the box that fell right at the feet of the sliding McTominay. He turned the ball in from close range, and restored United’s two goal cushion. 3-1!

Again though, Galatasaray proved they have a great resilience about them. They won another free kick in a dangerous area just 7 minutes after the McTominay goal, similar to the position they had at the opposite end in the first half. Ziyech stepped up to take the free kick again, and he forced Onana to dive to his right to try and make the save. Unfortunately for Onana, the ball somehow ricocheted off his hand backwards and into the net. Ziyech wheeled away in celebration as Rams Park erupted, but this goal was down to Onana completely misjudging the shot and failing to keep it out. It was a pretty bad howler from him, and it continued United’s unfortunate trend of goalkeeping errors leading to opposition goals in the Champions League. More on Onana below.

The home side were galvanized by the mistake, and suddenly started playing with a lot more confidence. They got their equalizer on 71 minutes when winger Kerem Aktürkoğlu buried a fine shot past Onana from just inside the penalty area. He was found by an excellent pass over the top from Ziyech, with the United defense undone. United were guilty of poor marking on this goal, and they perhaps could have done more to stop the build-up from the back. But take nothing away from Ziyech and Aktürkoğlu. It was a goal of quality, and probably deserved from a neutral point of view.

The match ended 3-3, although many in Istanbul would have felt that Galatasaray were the better side and likely should have had a 4th if not for VAR overturning a penalty against United. The home side were particularly better in the second half. I hate to pin this result on one man because football is team sport, but Onana really let the side down in this match. There’s no getting around it. The first goal likely should have been saved, and the second one definitely should have been saved. The defense has really cost us in this group stage campaign. We have conceded 14 goals in these 5 matches, several of which were the fault of Onana. You can’t reasonably pin all the blame on him, but this was a guy that was touted for his ability to play in the Champions League. He was very good for Inter Milan in this tournament last year, helping them to reach the final. But for whatever reason this year, he has not done well. The defense doesn’t help him sometimes, but other times it’s very unclear what Onana is doing between the sticks. That said, he has been very good domestically this season. He is one of the better keepers in the Premier League, but for some reason his play drops significantly in Europe. Despite the bad match today, I still believe in Onana for a variety of reasons and I am sure he will improve.

The draw leaves United’s hopes for qualification to the knockout stages hanging by the proverbial thread. They are rock bottom of Group A on 4 points. They not only need to defeat Bayern Munich at Old Trafford in the final game, they then have to hope for a draw between FC Copenhagen and Galatasaray. Any other result in that match will see the Danish or Turkish side qualify in lieu of United. If United finish third in the group they would qualify for the Europa League, but I personally do not want us to have to participate in that tournament this year. The last thing we need would be more fixtures in far away countries that would most likely end up being meaningless. We need to either crash out completely in 4th, or hope that fortune favors us and we finish 2nd. The Premier League and FA Cup are way more important to me personally this year than the Europa League. My prediction for that final match day? United beats Bayern, but it ultimately doesn’t matter because Galatasaray is going to beat Copenhagen and clinch 2nd place. United will end up in the Europa League thanks to finishing 3rd, much to my would-be chagrin.

Taken as a one-off, this wasn’t a bad result. 3-3 in Istanbul is usually nothing to be ashamed of. But what bothers me the most about this match is that United blew a 2 goal lead twice! They were up 2-0 and then again at 3-1, and at this level of professional football that should be a victory. The good quality goal for Galatasaray to make it 3-3 never should have been anything more than a consolation goal. This team clearly still has issues with mental toughness and resiliency. There have been several occasions both in Europe and domestically where United have blown leads this season, and manager Erik ten Hag needs to sort that out immediately. To be fair, United have seen out their fair share of close victories this season as well, but they seem to crumble when resiliency is needed the most. This current iteration/generation of United players need to learn how to consistently win games, and that will only come with more time and practice at it. They do seem to be getting better about managing leads, but this match was a stark reminder that there is still a ways to go.

United face another difficult test in their next match, a trip to St. James’ Park to play Newcastle on December 2nd in the Prem. This will be a tough match, but also a great opportunity for United to build on their away win at Everton last weekend.

Glazers Out!

Manchester United in Turmoil – But How Do They Fix It?

United’s last two matches have been nothing short of piss-poor. That’s strong language coming out of the gate for this post, but every word of it is true. United were defeated in the Manchester Derby by Man City at the weekend 3-0, and then they were similarly drubbed by Newcastle United in the League/Carabao/EFL Cup by the same score yesterday. There were very few positives to take from either match. They were uninspiring in attack and porous in defense. Just bad football all around. Yes, City and Newcastle are good sides, and losing to good sides isn’t the worst thing in the world, but the absolutely listless manner in which we are losing is unacceptable. It’s not even close!

Rumors are flying everywhere about the status of the club and what the real source of the problems are. Unfortunately, without being present in the locker room for training sessions and matches every day, there is no way to suss out the real problem(s). Any and all media speculation, including from me, should be taken with a grain of salt. Every major sports news outlet claims to know what the problems are based on the aforementioned rumors, but no one aside from the players, manager, and club staff really know what’s going on.

Let’s approach this from the point of view of trying to get better. Okay, it’s been a crap start to the season. United are 8th in the Premier League table, they are out of the League Cup already, and they are second from bottom in their Champions League group. A decidedly poor start by the standards of this club. But alright, let’s acknowledge the poor start and then move on by asking the key questions – how do they fix it? How do they go about improving results on the pitch?

Some have called for the sacking of manager Erik ten Hag. While it’s true that his tactics have been stale and confusing at times this season, and he could stand to change things up a bit, I don’t think firing ETH will really change things in the long run. It’s the simplest way to change things, but will it really do anything? I doubt it. For one, who do you replace him with? There are no obvious candidates with the proper coaching pedigree available right now. For two, his tactics last season were largely successful. Is he really the biggest problem? Or is it that the players aren’t listening to him?

The majority of commenters online are laying blame at the feet of the players these days. It’s hard to disagree with those comments at times. It’s true that injuries have forced some of them to play out of position, but that’s not an excuse to not try hard. There’s no denying that our forwards – Marcus Rashford, Anthony Martial, Bruno Fernandes, Rasmus Højlund, Antony dos Santos, and Alejandro Garnacho – have all been extremely poor this season. There is just one measly Premier League goal amidst all that talent, and it was scored by Rashford in a losing effort against Arsenal. The attack is just so static and uninspiring. No one makes runs into the box. No one tries to play a dangerous ball into the box. They just bring the ball into the attacking third and then stop! Is that at the instruction of ETH? Is it the players not understanding what ETH wants? Worst yet, is it that they simply don’t care to try? Are they upset with ETH over something and don’t trust him anymore? I think no matter what the real problem is, it can’t be denied that at least part of the problem is that the dynamic of the locker room has shifted for one reason or another. I think there is a negativity surrounding the relationship between ETH and the majority of his players that wasn’t there last season. However, whatever the problem, there is no excuse not to work hard. Every single one of these first-team players is making hundreds of thousands of pounds every week to play this game. It’s the absolute least they can do to run their asses off every match! Every single player who claims to love playing for United needs to come out and show that.

Of course, yet another entity to blame is ownership. My gripes with the Glazer family are well-documented on this blog, and as owners of this club ultimately a lot of the blame is on them. The structure of this club is absolutely garbage, in the sense that it’s unclear who is in charge of what tasks and what goals each person is trying to achieve. Manager of Man City, Pep Guardiola, recently took an indirect swipe at United when he suggested that the reason for City’s success is that everyone at that club is on the same page and has the same goals. Their manager, sporting directors, and owners are all aligned on what they want and need to do. Now, Pep can be a little bit flippant at times and there’s a lot more to success than just being aligned, but I have to admit that he has a point. The owners need to set the tone of what the club needs to be, and the manager/sporting directors/players all have to align with that. The Glazers are not doing that, put mildly. There’s no accountability from them, and that trickles down to every level of the club. If they don’t really care about results and are only in it for the money, that attitude can and will permeate. Glazers Out, now and forever.

It has been reported by several outlets that the Glazers will eventually be selling 25% of this club to Sir Jim Ratcliffe, a British billionaire who grew up supporting United. It is also rumored that Ratcliffe and his people will be taking over football operations and will be re-building the structure of the club. If that’s true, he has a mountain of work ahead of him. We have players that need to be sold, more that need to be brought in, and serious renovations are needed at both Old Trafford and Carrington training ground. The leaky roof on our beloved stadium is the perfect metaphor for this club’s current issues – a once great entity that has fallen into disrepair due to mismanagement and neglect.

In short, there is no simple solution to the club’s problems and no instant fix. We need an over-arching and holistic solution that no one seems to be interested in providing. There’s also very little to feel optimistic about. The Glazers need to sell, ETH needs to improve his tactics, and the players need to try harder. We didn’t get to this point accidentally. This is what happens when businessmen (and not football men) are allowed to own a club. Financial investment is a major aspect of the modern game, and United have fallen far behind on that front. We’re a joke right now. Every other club in Europe is laughing at us, and rightly so. Many of them aren’t even laughing as loudly as they once were, because at this point the tepid mediocrity isn’t even funny anymore. It’s just sad.

United have an away trip to Fulham in west London up next on November 4th. Any kind of positive result would be welcome, but I’m not holding my breath.

Glazers Out!

Champions League – A Narrow and Nervous Win Over Copenhagen

Manchester United played host to Danish champions FC Copenhagen earlier today at Old Trafford in the Champions League. This was a match between the bottom two teams in Group A, with Copenhagen in third on 1 point and United dead last with zero. The Champions League is the most prestigious club competition in world football, and United are a team that need to be consistently making deep runs in this tournament. That’s the goal, at least. Today, the Red Devils and manager Erik ten Hag just needed three points to pick themselves up off the mat and get back into contention in the group. Only the top two teams from each group advance to the knockout rounds, and United would have a monumental task of getting into those top two spots if they lost today. The same can be said for Copenhagen, who have only been marginally better than United so far in the group.

The match got underway after the laying of a wreath in the center circle and moment’s silence in honor of Sir Bobby Charlton, and it was immaculately observed by both sets of fans. It’s always jarring when 75,000+ people previously being loud suddenly go completely quiet, but it’s the least that can be done for a man of Charlton’s stature. A classy move by the away fans as well to sing his name before the match started.

As has been the case many times this season, the opposition dominated the first half. They struck the left hand post of keeper Andre Onana’s goal around 15 minutes in or so, with the rebound fortunately going out of play. Copenhagen were simply the better side, and they were likely instructed by manager Jacob Neestrup to try and find the early goal. He would have known that United are a mentally fragile side, and that a goal in the opening 20 minutes or so would likely go a long way to getting a good result for his team. United were able to maintain some possession as the half wore on, but it was fairly harmless possession in the sense that we weren’t really doing anything with the ball aside from passing it along the back line. The attack was rather static, and I don’t recall too many real chances for the home side in the opening half. After 45 minutes it was 0-0, a score that suited Copenhagen perfectly well. United would need to find a winner though to keep qualification realistic.

Midfielder Christian Eriksen was brought on at halftime, and the play from United generally improved. Eriksen is very composed on the ball and always knows what pass to play in order to keep possession, which is precisely why he was brought on. United were creating more half-chances here and there, but the final pass or shot would always be just slightly off. Copenhagen weren’t as potent going forward generally speaking, but they still looked very lively when breaking on the counter-attack. The clock was on their side, as well. Every minute that ticked by was one minute closer to them getting a positive result away from home.

The opening goal in this match came on 72 minutes, and it was none other than the much-maligned center back Harry Maguire who delivered it. A cross into the box from a corner by midfielder Bruno Fernandes was only half-cleared by the Copenhagen defense, and the ball was recycled out to Eriksen on the right wing. He delivered a high and arcing cross of his own back into the box, and it found the head of Maguire. He had beaten his marker to get in behind the defense, and he stooped down low to get his head to the ball. The headerhit the ground first, but then bounced up and over Copenhagen keeper Kamil Grabara for 1-0. Maguire wheeled away in celebration, and got a rousing reception from the Stretford End. There was a quick VAR check for offside, but Maguire was deemed to be onside and the goal stood. What a huge goal, both for Maguire and United! He’s put some real shifts in this season, and today was his best. He finally used that massive head of his to it’s full potential. 1-0 to United!

The drama only escalated from there though. Copenhagen struggled to create clear chances in the final 15 minutes or so, but they were temporarily rescued by the referee when they were awarded a penalty in the dying seconds of stoppage time. Midfielder Scott McTominay attempted to clear a bouncing ball with a high boot, and the ref deemed it to be dangerous play. A little soft if you ask me, but I have seen penalties given for less. Forward Jordan Larsson (son of former United striker Henrik Larsson) stepped up to take the penalty. There was a little bit of gamesmanship on this penalty as well. Substitute United winger Alejandro Garnacho (who had missed a clear chance on a breakaway earlier in the match) was seen scuffing up the penalty spot with the bottom of his cleat while several other players were all crowded around the referee to argue the decision. This has become a fairly common practice in world football in recent years, but it can only be done if the referee is distracted and not paying attention.

Still, Larsson had a chance to ruin United’s evening and largely ruin their hopes for qualification if he could bury the penalty. He stepped up and struck it cleanly, only to see Onana beat away the shot with his trailing hand as he dived to the left. The ball bounced away out of play, and the referee blew his whistle immediately afterwards! He had done it! Onana saved the penalty, and United were victorious. Onana was mobbed by his teammates both on the field and on the bench, and it was a massive moment for him personally as well. He’s been guilty of some absolute howlers this season, so for him to make that save was nothing short of monumental. It will be great for his confidence going forward!

Speaking of going forward, the match today felt like the start of something for the club. It wasn’t pretty, but it was a massive three points and huge for the confidences of Maguire and Onana. The Red Devils must capitalize on this momentum, now. Everyone will be feeling very positive about today, and rightfully so. But it means nothing if they come out against Manchester City on Sunday and are flat and tepid again. The players need to believe in themselves. If Maguire and Onana can overcome their frankly poor starts to the season and play like they did today, anyone can.

Self-belief and confidence are important, but so are tactics. I was again unimpressed with the first half display from the team, as I have been many times this season. I know there are a lot of injuries right now, but that does not excuse the poor play from attackers like Bruno, Marcus Rashford, Antony dos Santos, and others. There’s just no creativity on the ball going forward. No one moves around, no one makes runs, and the finishing has been very bad even when they do get the ball into a good position. ETH needs to re-think whatever it is he is telling the players to do, because it isn’t working. We were again saved by moments of individual brilliance today, and that is an unsustainable plan. It’s mind-boggling, because ETH’s tactics and substitutions were so brilliant last season. Have opposing teams figured us out? Is it an issue with effort on the part of the players? Is the plan not being effectively communicated to the team? One can only wonder. I still like ETH’s subs and adjustments for the most part, but the tactical plan at the outset of many matches this season, including this one, leaves a lot to be desired.

United are now third in Group A, just one point off second-place Galatasaray. The matches do not get any easier from here on out for United, though. They have to play away in Denmark and Türkiye still, with the final match of the group having them play host to Bayern Munich. The next two matches in this group will be vital to United qualifying for the second round. Meanwhile, as mentioned above, United have the daunting task of playing City at Old Trafford next Sunday in the Manchester Derby. Any positive result from that match would be welcomed. City are not as good as they were last year, but they still have more than enough firepower to cause United problems.

Glory Glory Man United! Glazers Out!

Manchester United – This One Is For Cathy Ferguson

Manchester United’s inconsistent form has continued the past few weeks. There was a win over Crystal Palace in the League Cup, followed by a dismal loss to the same side in the Premier League a few days later. United also lost to Turkish side Galatasaray in midweek in the Champions League, in a match marred by controversy. The main reason for this sputtering form is bad defending. The Red Devils have more leaks in defense right now than the Titanic post-iceberg, but that is largely due to injuries. Defenders Raphael Varane, Lisandro Martinez, Victor Lindelof, Luke Shaw, and Aaron Wan-Bissaka have all been bitten by the injury bug at the exact same time. That’s the entire preferred back four out all at once. To make the atmosphere even more negative around Old Trafford, supporters were saddened by the loss of Cathy Ferguson, wife of former manager and United legend Sir Alex Ferguson. Her influence on this club is the biggest of any person who has never actually worked or played for us. She was the one who single-handedly convinced Ferguson not to retire when he initially wanted to in 2002, thus ensuring another decade of success and trophies for Manchester United. My deepest condolences to Sir Alex, the Ferguson family, and anyone who ever met Cathy.

The club needed a response today. Something needed to happen, and thankfully it did. United took on Brentford FC earlier today at Old Trafford in the Premier League, with three points being the order of the day. Unfortunately, United found themselves down a goal on 26 minutes after midfielder Casemiro needlessly gave the ball away, and Bees midfielder Mathias Jensen was on hand to sweep home a low finish past United keeper Andre Onana. United had been lackluster up until that moment, and they were punished for their usual complacency.

The poor play continued until about the last half an hour or so. Manager Erik ten Hag brought on striker Anthony Martial and winger Antony dos Santos around that time, with the ineffective forward Marcus Rashford among those coming off. United improved significantly with these changes, although Martial and substitute winger Alejandro Garnacho were wasteful in front of goal. As the clock ticked towards full time, ETH made another key substitution – bringing on midfielder and Scotland international Scott McTominay for make-shift left back Sofyan Amrabat.

Six minutes of stoppage time was given by the referee, and United finally got an equalizer on 93 minutes thanks to a tidy finish from McTominay. Brentford failed to clear their lines, and McTominay showed great predatory instinct to beat Brentford keeper Thomas Strakosha at his near post. Old Trafford erupted in celebration when United finally found a way through for 1-1.

McTominay and United weren’t finished, though. The Red Devils won a free kick near the halfway line on the right wing, just as the clock hit the 97th minute of play. Had United not already scored, the referee may have blown his whistle and not permitted us to take the free kick. Midfielder Bruno Fernandes played a high aerial ball into the box, and it found the head of center back Harry Maguire. Maguire was on the left side of the box, and his header back towards the goal found McTominay on a run. McTominay had ghosted in front of his marker intelligently, and he looped the pass from Maguire up over Strakosha and into the back of the net for 2-1. A winner in Fergie Time! Absolutely amazing. The ref blew his whistle shortly after that and United miraculously emerged with a victory!

The storylines from this one are fantastic. A Scottish player scores two goals in stoppage time to win the match the day after the death of Cathy Ferguson. It was absolutely magical and it was desperately needed for the club. Here’s to hoping Sir Alex can smile about something now. Well done to McTominay and the rest of the lads for not quitting. Effort is something that has been lacking this season, and I hope the players remember that they are never out of a match. They have to keep fighting. They have to keep running at the opposition and taking chances. United have been incredibly short on luck this season too, so it was about time a roll of the dice went our way. There are still many issues with these players and the manager’s tactics that need to be addressed, but credit to ETH for getting his substitutions right (this time). He changed the game with those subs, and Brentford failed to put the game away. Big shoutout to the much-maligned Maguire as well. He takes a lot of flak when he doesn’t play well, but he was a rock in central defense today and that needs to be noted.

Here’s to hoping that this win is the spark the club needed to get back into consistently good form. A win like this one can change the mentality of the players and fans from negativity and pessimism to self-believe and positivity. United head into the October international break with a win, which is all anyone can ask for. They are now out of action until October 21st, when they travel north to play Sheffield United. England have a friendly against Australia on October 13th, and then there is a crucial Euro 2024 qualifier against Italy at Wembley on October 17th.

Glory Glory Man United! Glazers Out!

Manchester United in Disarray

The Red Devils lost to Brighton & Hove Albion on Saturday at Old Trafford, with the final score being 3-1. Midfielder Hannibal Mejbri got an impressive consolation goal, but the match had already been lost by that point. United were out-passed, out-possessed, and generally outplayed by a talented Brighton side. There was a goal disallowed for striker Rasmus Højlund that probably should have been allowed to stand, but there were a ton of problems for United that had nothing to do with the referee. Seagulls manager Roberto De Zerbi deserves praise and credit for building a team that consistently overperforms and exceeds their budgetary limitations.

Conversely, this has been statistically the poorest start to a United season since the 1970s. They have only won 2 of their first 5 opening matches, and have looked lackluster in all of them. A lot of things are going wrong at this club right now, some of which is bad luck, but a lot of it is avoidable. It seems like every day, even when there is no match to be played, more and more negative headlines keep rolling in.

The bad luck is mainly coming in the form of injuries, although at some point one has to question why injuries are always a concern for this club season after season. Nevertheless, we have a starting 11 of injured players in the training room right now, and that is a big part of the reason why the results are so poor. You need your most talented players to win games, but moreover you need those talented players playing alongside one another consistently to develop an understanding and chemistry. If that’s not happening due to injuries or other reasons, the team will simply not play as well.

But the injuries are just one aspect of United’s problems right now. A much bigger issue, and one that is completely within the players’ control, is EFFORT. If I had a dollar for every time a star player was caught being lazy and not giving a full effort this season, I could pay off my considerable student loan debt in full. I am sick and tired of seeing grown men who make six figures EVERY WEEK not giving a shit about playing hard. Playing football is the ONLY THING they have to do, and for whatever reason they are not playing their best. Out of the 13-14 players who touched the pitch on Saturday, maybe 4 or 5 of them truly gave their best efforts. It’s unacceptable. Manager Erik ten Hag needs to start dropping the big names from the starting line-ups to send a message that no one’s spot in this team is safe. A starting spot is earned, not given. It might be worth fielding a team of academy players for a match just to send a message to the rest of the squad. Right now, the culture of this team is awful and it is on ETH to remedy the issue.

Another issue is tactics, which is related to the injury crisis. Despite all the spending in the summer, we still somehow do not have the players to play in the style ETH demands. He wants us to control possession in the middle of the park, while also running a counter-press when out of possession. That can be an effective style of play with the proper players who are properly motivated, but as I have said before on this blog, tactics don’t matter if your players don’t care to play hard. There have also been some questionable substitutions made by ETH in recent games, which again is on him to fix. He did well tactically last season, so the regression so far this year is extremely concerning.

There are also problems off the pitch. Winger/forward Mason Greenwood was finally sold to Spanish side Getafe, and I thought we had done well to excise that particular tumor from the locker room. However, winger Antony dos Santos has also found himself at the center of a domestic violence scandal in recent weeks, with numerous allegations being made by his former girlfriend. Antony denies all allegations, but he has stepped away from the team and isn’t playing right now until the club determines the best way to proceed. Lastly, winger Jadon Sancho has not been selected to play recently, supposedly due to a locker room spat with ETH over punctuality at training. There has been a lot of back and forth in the media between Sancho and the manager, and that kind of distraction is always bad for team chemistry. I do like that ETH is holding players accountable and making everyone adhere to the same standards, but he needs to figure out a way to motivate Sancho and get the best out of him. Right now, that isn’t happening with any of the players.

And of course, there is always the bigger picture to consider as well. Any time there is a problem with a business, the owner ultimately carries all responsibility for it. The Glazers are no exception. I realize they were not on the pitch on Saturday and they do not set the team’s lineups and tactics, but their greasy fingerprints are all over the negative climate at the club. They do not invest their own money in the club or it’s facilities, and indeed they actively take money out of it. It is probable that the injury issues year after year are related to no investment from ownership in the medical staff and training room. They did spend (the club’s) money a little bit in the summer to bring in new players, but it is rumored that many of ETH’s first-choice targets were overlooked due to cost. Their biggest sin though is their laissez-faire approach that has left this club in a state of salutary neglect. They don’t care if the team wins too much, as long as they keep making money. This attitude of “we don’t really care” trickles down to everyone at the club, from the players to the training staff to the kit people to the janitors that clean the stadium after matches. If the owners don’t care about winning consistently, why should the players?

So yes, it’s a mess right now. This team needs to respond to the adversity, and it has to happen soon. The title is already gone, and the top-4 is in serious jeopardy if the team keeps playing in an unmotivated fashion. ETH’s seat will also become incredibly hot if the results do not improve, as will the seat of Director of Football John Murtough. Of course though, nothing will fundamentally change at this club for the better until the Glazers sell the team and get out of town.

It doesn’t get any easier for the Red Devils in the next match either, as they must travel to Germany for a Champions League group stage match against German champions Bayern Munich on Wednesday. Needless to say, I don’t have high expectations.

Glazers Out!

Premier League: United Come From Behind to Beat Forest

Manchester United hosted East Midlands club Nottingham Forest earlier today at a rainy Old Trafford in the Premier League. The Red Devils were looking to bounce back from their disappointing defeat last weekend away at Tottenham, but they were hindered by the losses of left back Luke Shaw and midfielder Mason Mount through injury. Forest meanwhile were riding high after they beat Sheffield United last weekend, and they knew that they didn’t necessarily need a victory today. Forest and manager Steve Cooper are merely trying to stay up like they were last season, and anything on top of that would be icing on the cake. Earning a draw would be a more than satisfactory result for them. All of the pressure was on United manager Erik ten Hag and the rest of the squad to deliver a performance the supporters could feel good about.

Forest were the first to score though, and they did so within two minutes of kickoff. United had actually won a corner, but the cross into the box was cleared away and back out towards the halfway line. Unfortunately, United striker Marcus Rashford (who was covering defensively for some reason) was caught flat-footed, and he was beaten to the bouncing ball by Forest striker Taiwo Awoniyi. Rashford is normally not a defender, and Awoniyi was at least a yard ahead of the rest of the United defense as they had committed so many men forward. Awoniyi carried the ball into the box with United keeper Andre Onana retreating, and he finally got a shot away under a challenge from Rashford. The shot fooled Onana and rolled into the goal despite not having a ton of power on it. Onana maybe could have done better to go out and challenge Awoniyi, and Rashford has to be quicker to the ball if he is going to be tasked with defensive cover on corner kicks. Regardless, it was 1-0 Forest and those who had travelled north from Trentside were in celebration mode.

United’s misery was further compounded just two minutes later, when Forest got a second goal. Winger Brennan Johnson won a foul on the right wing after being brought down by deputizing left back Diogo Dalot. Forest midfielder Morgan Gibbs-White stepped up to take the free kick, and he whipped in a sublime ball to the center of the box. Forest center back Willy Boly was standing in the area, and he simply re-directed the ball down and to Onana’s left with his head. It rolled over the line and the rapturous celebration from the away fans’ section that hadn’t really died down from the first goal was re-ignited anew. Very poor set-piece marking from United on this one. Boly didn’t even have to jump to get to the cross. A good ball from Gibbs-White and a controlled header from Boly to be sure, but someone in red needed to get in the way of that one. It was the fastest United had ever gone down 2-0 at Old Trafford, and it took just 3 minutes and 47 seconds.

It was the worst possible opening four minutes for United, but it would be unfair to say that United did not improve after that. They took some time to re-establish possession and start creating chances, and they got their opening goal on 17 minutes from midfielder Christian Eriksen. Fellow midfielder Bruno Fernandes had launched a long-range shot towards goal that Forest keeper Matt Turner could only palm away, and it fell to the feet of striker Anthony Martial off to the left of the goal. Martial played it backwards towards Rashford on the left side of the box, and Rashford beat his marker (Forest right back Serge Aurier) to the end line and played the ball along the ground. Eriksen had made a run towards goal, and he deflected the cross home with the outside of his right foot. It was the deftest of touches, but Turner couldn’t keep it out and United had a lifeline at 2-1.

Midfielder Casemiro really should have made it 2-2 on 25 minutes when he missed an open goal with his headed attempt. Turner and the Forest defense all missed the cross in from the corner completely and it fell straight to him. It’s possible the rain had made the ball slicker than usual which caused it to skid on the surface of the pitch a little, but Casemiro will be wondering for ages how he missed given that he was all alone in front of an open net. The pitch was only getting more and more damp, but the chances conversely dried up for a bit. At half time it was 2-1, with Forest definitely the happier of the two locker rooms.

United got an equalizer on 51 minutes, and this time it was the result of a set piece. Casemiro made amends for his earlier miss when he volleyed home a headed cross from Bruno. Bruno had also taken the initial free kick, playing it diagonally backwards to Rashford about 25 yards from goal. Bruno then darted into the box diagonally, leaving his marker in the dust. He headed the wondrous ball from Rashford back across goal, and Casemiro was all by himself yet again. This time he managed to take the ball on his knee then hit it home from about 3 yards out on the volley. No doubts about that one. A great set-piece goal from United, but the Forest back line were definitely guilty of ball-watching. 2-2, and United smelled blood.

Winger Antony dos Santos nearly got a third as the clock struck 54 minutes, but his wicked curler of a shot was pushed wide by Turner. Things got worse for Forest on 67 minutes when center back Joe Worrall was shown a straight red card by the referee for bringing down Bruno after Bruno had sprinted past him. The challenge itself wasn’t super aggressive or physical, but Worrall definitely grabbed Bruno’s shirt/shorts while pulling him back. Bruno went down as a result, and the referee was well-positioned to come in and deliver the red. Worrall was just too slow to react, and it cost him and his team.

The comeback for United was completed on 76 minutes, when Bruno converted from the penalty spot. Rashford once again got the better of his marker on the left wing, and as he darted into the box he was clipped by the knee of Forest midfielder Danilo. He went to ground, and the referee pointed to the spot immediately. Rashford had been dangerous on the left wing all match, and despite not scoring today he played his best game so far this season. Turner did well to guess the correct direction of the penalty, but the placement and power on the shot from Bruno left him no chance. 3-2 to United!

Interestingly, it was Forest in the ascendancy for much of the remaining time despite being down to 10 men. They created several decent to good chances, and they were worthy of an equalizer. Onana had to be alert to deny yet another effort from Boly, and Forest striker Chris Wood really should have got contact on a peach of a cross from winger (and former United player) Anthony Elanga. After an agonizingly long 13 minutes of stoppage time, the ref finally blew his whistle and United were winners on the day.

Another victory is always good, and no one can rightly say this match wasn’t entertaining. United made it hard on themselves again, though. They conceded 2 goals in the opening 4 minutes, but then kicked into gear and scored the next 3. It’s very clear that Rashford needs to play on the left wing. Whether ETH likes it or not, Rashford is not a center forward. He caused so many problems for Forest down the left hand side today. Bruno was Man of the Match, and indeed this was probably one of his best performances in a United shirt. He is the catalyst for us. His creativity and drive in attacking midfield is essential to everything ETH wants to do tactically. He must continue to play as the number 10 in behind a striker, and not be shuffled out to right wing where he is half as effective. Good games also from Casemiro, Eriksen, and right back Aaron Wan-Bissaka,

I also want to give recognition to the United supporters who staged a sit-in at Old Trafford after the final whistle. Thousands of Red Devils supporters congregated in the opposite ends of the stadium to demonstrate their collective disdain for the Glazer family, owners of Manchester United. The familiar chant “We Want Glazers Out” rang out around the stadium for at least 30-45 minutes after the match had ended, with the intent being that the Glazers once and for all sell the club to another owner. There were rumblings of their intent to sell back in the summer, but it doesn’t appear that any actual progress has been made on a sale. It’s not even clear if they want to sell anymore, and hopefully this protest reminds them that they need to go. For all the reasons I’ve listed over the years writing this blog, Glazers Out!

United face a difficult test next Sunday, Sept. 3rd when they travel to London for a Premier League match with title-contenders Arsenal. United’s away form against big clubs simply must improve. If you want to win the trophy, you have to win consistently on the road. It’s one thing to win at home against a (no disrespect) bottom-half side like Forest, but it is another to go on the road and win at Arsenal. There is hope however that there will be a debut for new signing and striker Rasmus Højlund.

Glory Glory Man United!

Premier League: Defeat at Tottenham

Manchester United travelled south to London earlier today for match #2 of their Premier League schedule against Tottenham Hotspur at Tottenham Hotspur Stadium. They would be looking to improve on their opening day performance last Monday, a match which they won but looked far from convincing in doing so. Tottenham and new manager Ange Postecoglu were looking for their first 3 points of the season, having drawn their opening match last weekend. United manager Erik ten Hag named an unchanged lineup from the last game, which raised some eyebrows among the pundits pre-match. Everyone at the club knows that our away form against the bigger sides needs to improve, as it was abysmal last season and the main reason why we didn’t challenge for the title. This was Spurs’ first home match since the departure of talismanic striker Harry Kane to Bayern Munich, with many wondering how they are going to replace his goal production.

The first half started strongly for Tottenham, but United settled in a little and began establishing possession after the first 10 minutes or so. Half chances and narrowly missed opportunities were the theme of the first 35 minutes. Tottenham were struggling to play the ball out from the back, but United were again (like the previous match) disjointed in attack and not really clicking with one another. United had a penalty shout when the ball struck the hand of Spurs center back Cristian Romero in the box, but VAR confirmed referee Michael Oliver’s decision to not award a spot kick. Romero’s hand was up, but it was deemed to be close enough to his body to not be in an “unnatural” position, whatever that means this week.

Midfielder Bruno Fernandes should have put United ahead 1-0 right around 36 minutes or so, when a pass over the top found him all alone about 6-7 yards in front of the Tottenham goal. He tried to re-direct the pass into the far corner, but his header was far too powerful and it went over the bar. It was an embarrassing miss given how much time and space he had to put it away. Spurs keeper Guglielmo Vicario was relieved to see it go over, because Bruno is normally ruthless from that close.

Tottenham had the next best chances of the half, with right back Pedro Porro striking the crossbar of the United goal with keeper Andre Onana beaten. Tottenham then struck the woodwork again just a few seconds later, although this time it was via a deflected cross off Red Devils center back Lisandro Martinez. It was only down to fortune that the ball did not go in. At halftime it was 0-0, and while United were probably slightly better than the first half of the match last week, they still had nothing to show for it. Postecoglu was undoubtedly the happier manager going into the locker rooms.

Tottenham raised their urgency a bit in the early part of the second half and were rewarded for their efforts on 49 minutes with the opening goal from defensive midfielder Pape Matar Sarr. Spurs winger Dejan Kulusevski ran down the right wing with the ball virtually unchallenged before getting to the end line and playing an aerial cross back across the face of the goal. The ball took an unlucky deflection off Martinez before falling straight to the feet of Sarr, who buried a shot into the roof of Onana’s net. Spurs got a bit lucky to be sure, but what on earth was United left back Luke Shaw doing in the build-up? He was 20 yards off Kulusevski, and he didn’t bother to come over and make a challenge until the Swedish winger was already in the box! Very poor defending from a player who is usually sturdy at the back. Most of the blame for this goal lies at his feet.

I was looking for a sharp and positive response from United after going down, but none was forthcoming. It was dismal, really. Tottenham, led by captain and superstar winger Son Heung-min, were dominating United down their attacking left wing. It seemed like they had an extra man on that side every time they brought it forward. When United did break up an attack and get on the ball, they resulted to playing hopeful long passes instead of playing it through midfield. They couldn’t maintain any possession and were giving the ball away needlessly. Winger Antony dos Santos did manage to strike Vicario’s post just after the Spurs goal, but beyond that they looked completely toothless.

Some befuddling decisions from ETH did not help the situation. A triple change was made on 63 minutes, where he brought on winger Jadon Sancho, midfielder Christian Eriksen, and right back Diogo Dalot. Marcus Rashford, ineffective on the day, was kept as the central striker. Bruno was pushed out on to the right wing as well. Whatever the manager’s idea was, it did not work. Sancho had one or two flashes of good play, but beyond him everyone looked rather lost and disinterested in trying to get back into the game.

To add insult to injury, Tottenham got a second goal on 83 minutes, and this was a comically bad goal to concede. No luck for Tottenham this time, just more miscommunication and bad defending from United. A low and diagonal pass was played in to the United box from the left channel, with left back Ben Davies the intended recipient. Davies mishit the ball completely, but it took yet another deflection off Martinez and rolled into the goal with Onana wrong-footed. Just a terrible own-goal to concede in every way. There was no pressure on the ball in the left channel, and the back four were once again asleep at the wheel. United did not offer much of a response to this goal, either. They had more possession as the clock ticked towards 90 minutes, but aside from a few long-range efforts that did not trouble Vicario, they offered nothing. Spurs won 2-0.

Alright, damage report time. ETH deserves most of the criticism for this result. He named a starting 11 that did very little against Wolves. It’s clear after today that winger Alejandro Garnacho is not ready to start, yet. Antony was more wasteful than useful. Rashford was anonymous in the striker role for the second match in a row. Bruno missed a sitter, and then was shoved out to the right wing in the second half, which is not his preferred position. Midfielder Casemiro looked slow and off the pace yet again. Shaw went to sleep at the worst possible moment. Midfielder Mason Mount’s tactical role in the team is totally unclear. Why Sancho and fellow winger Facundo Pellistri are not starting is a complete mystery.

ETH really needs to get his tactics sorted out for the next match, and the team overall needs to play with a lot more urgency and desire. What’s worrying is that passion for the game is difficult to coach – either a player has it on the day or he doesn’t. ETH, club captain Bruno, and the other locker room leaders need to be giving each other a proper bollicking over this dismal match. Along with starts for Sancho and Pellistri, Rashford needs to be moved out to the left wing, where he feels most comfortable. Bruno needs to stay in the middle as an attacking midfielder too. It feels like ETH is trying to force a tactical plan that is not suited to the talents of our attacking players. We can’t win on the wings, we can’t play the ball through the middle, and we are still shit at set pieces. I trust ETH to make some positive changes, but they need to happen soon. Starting Anthony Martial at center forward next week will help, as will the addition of striker Rasmus Højlund once he is fully fit and ready to play. Supporters can’t rely on just Højlund to fix everything though. ETH needs to adjust his lineups and overall tactical plan.

There is still time for additional signings before the transfer window closes, but for various financial reasons, United need to clear out some current players before more can be signed. Center back Harry Maguire’s transfer to West Ham has fallen apart though, while ETH still seems to be trying to be rid of midfielder Scott McTominay. Again though, the overall tactical plan needs to be adjusted. He was exceptional at implementing a plan last season that the players bought into, and now he must do that again. One loss is not the end of the world, but these losses will multiply without changes being made.

Next match is at Old Trafford against Nottingham Forest on August 26th in the Premier League. The Red Devils need to bounce back, and they need to bounce back with passion. As always, Glazers Out!