Premier League: An Impressive Victory at Everton

Manchester United traveled 30 miles west to Liverpool for a match against Everton FC at Goodison Park yesterday. This was the first match after the resumption of the international break, and the Red Devils were happy to have left back Luke Shaw back in the team after a long injury layoff. Manager Erik ten Hag handed a debut to 18 year-old midfielder Kobbie Mainoo, who started alongside midfielder Scott McTominay in the center of the pitch. Everton, their supporters, and manager Sean Dyche were definitely motivated to get a positive result in this match, having (wrongly, in my opinion) been docked 10 points by the Premier League for violations of the Financial Fair Play rules.

Despite the restless and raucous atmosphere inside Goodison, it was United who got off to a flying start just 3 minutes into the match when winger/forward Alejandro Garnacho opened the scoring with an absolutely stunning overhead bicycle kick. I could describe it in detail, but Bill Shakespeare himself couldn’t put the words together to describe this beauty of a strike!

The goal went viral quickly, and if you haven’t seen it, give it a watch. It was good play from United to get it up the pitch quickly, but the cross from right back Diogo Dalot was a little bit behind Garnacho. All credit to the 19 year-old Argentine for his technique and the audacity to pull off something so grand. 1-0 to United!

Everton were unmoved, however. Despite being behind, they were mostly the better side for the rest of the first half. Keeper Andre Onana was on hand to make a double save around the half hour mark, after which the ball was cleared off the line by Mainoo. The United defense was holding up alright, but in attack they were again struggling to create chances for a second goal. Despite Everton’s dominance, they couldn’t capitalize and it remained 1-0 at halftime.

United got their second goal on 50 minutes, thanks to finally catching a break from VAR. Striker Anthony Martial looked to have been fouled in the box by Everton right back (and former United player) Ashley Young, but the referee did not give a penalty and also booked Martial for diving. VAR checked the incident though, and upon replays it was clear that Young stuck his leg out and tripped Martial in an effort to get to the ball. Martial’s yellow was rescinded and a penalty was given. Initially, midfielder Bruno Fernandes had his hands on the ball to take the kick, but then he walked over and handed the ball to winger/forward Marcus Rashford. Rashford stepped up and buried the penalty into the upper-left corner of the goal, with Toffees keeper Jordan Pickford unable to do anything about it. Rashford has been in poor goal-scoring form this season, so perhaps Bruno sensed he needed this penalty to raise his confidence a bit. Aside from this goal though, Rashford had another poor performance. His passing and awareness were bad for most of the game. He does not seem to be injured, but rather distracted. His head isn’t in the game, as it were. A very recent post of his on social media indicates he is mourning the death of a family member, which may be part of the reason for his absent-minded play. If that’s the case, I don’t blame him at all for playing poor today. I hope he takes care of his mental health first and foremost, and I think the penalty will help with his confidence. 2-0 to United!

United continued to run at the Everton back-4 in search of a third, and came close a few times before eventually getting that third goal from Martial on 75 minutes. The ball was won in midfield thanks to a good press, and there was an exchange of passes between Martial, Bruno, and substitute winger Facundo Pellistri near and beyond the center circle. Pellistri played a return pass to Bruno on the edge of the area, who found Martial on a run just ahead of him with a beautifully weighted pass. The Everton defense was all over the place, and Martial took a touch to knock it into space before deftly lifting the ball over the onrushing Pickford. 3-0 to United, and game over! Everton managed to hit the crossbar a few minutes after the third goal, but there was no major action after that.

For the first time this season, United looked convincing away from home. This is also the first time they’ve won by multiple goals on the road in close to a full season. All three forwards scored in this match, which is yet another positive that hasn’t happened often this year. The first goal will grab all the headlines, but for me the most important goal was the third one. The first goal was a piece of individual brilliance, and the second goal was the result of VAR actually working as it’s supposed to, but the third was the exact sort of goal ETH has been looking for all season. We pressed in midfield, won the ball back in the center of the park, and were quickly away down to the other end to create a chance. Press + passing = goal. That is the footballing philosophy that ETH wants this team to employ. We don’t need 70% possession. We don’t need 500 passes. We need to get the ball, pass the ball, and score a goal. It’s what this team is built to do, and it’s fantastic that they finally remembered how to do it. Brilliant from Martial, Bruno, and Pellistri. Also a quick shout-out to Mainoo, who had a very impressive debut. He’s only 18, but bossed the midfield like a man ten years older. His passing, positioning, awareness, and tackling were all excellent.

The challenge now is to go out and do it again in the next match. Consistency must be the next step in the process. It’s no coincidence that some good form has returned now that some key players have finally returned from injury. Everton are not the best team of course, but to win like this in a very hostile atmosphere is nothing to minimize. This was a big win, no two ways about it. As I have said many times though, winning like this means nothing if they can’t go out and replicate it.

United have won 5 out of their last 6 Premier League matches, and find themselves 6th in the table. They are just four points from fourth, and a scant six points off the top. They next play Galatasaray in Istanbul on Wednesday, which will make Goodison look like a tea party in terms of the atmosphere. Turkiye is an insanely difficult place for foreign clubs to play, and frankly I won’t be upset if the result is less than positive. The European campaign this season may already be doomed due to previous results, and I don’t want the club to have to play in the Europa League for the rest of the year should they fail to finish 2nd in the group. Let’s give it a good effort, but if we lose it’s not the end of the world. This team needs to focus on the Prem and the FA Cup the rest of the season.

Glory Glory Man United! Glazers Out!

Manchester United: Victory Over Luton Town and Big Premier League News

Sorry for the delay in writing this match report. I started a new job this week and had to focus on that. Much to my chagrin, this blog does not pay the bills!

United defeated newly-promoted Luton Town 1-0 in a nervy win at Old Trafford on November 11th. The goal was from center back Victor Lindelof, who swept home with a high finish on 59 minutes after the Hatters failed to properly clear their lines. While the scoreline was a narrow one, United could have easily had 2 or 3 goals if not for some woeful finishing by winger Alejandro Garnacho and forward Marcus Rashford. However, the positive news is that they were consistently creating chances against a team defending in the low block. That is something that has not really happened this season, so it was good to see a bit more creativity. Yes, the finishing must improve, but there was a direction and purpose about the team in this match. Manager Erik ten Hag can hang his hat on that improvement. A win is a win of course, but more goals will need to be scored so as to improve on United’s pitiful goal differential.

United went into the November international break 6th in the Premier League table on 21 points, having won 4 of their last 5 matches in the domestic league. Given how crap they’ve been to start this season, things could be much worse. They are 7 points off Man City in first place, and 5 points off of Tottenham in fourth place. The team must continue to improve and get healthy, but things could be a lot worse. United will travel to Liverpool to play Everton on November 26th, after the international break ends. England play their final two Euro 2024 qualifiers this month, with one of them happening today against Malta at Wembley. I will do a separate post after the final qualifying match against North Macedonia on Monday, November 20th to recap all of the action.

Speaking of Everton though, there was some absolutely massive news announced today by the Football Association (FA) concerning them. It was announced today that Everton would be docked 10 points for violations of the rules surrounding Financial Fair Play (FFP). The FFP rules are often murky and difficult to understand even for the most diligent and learned of football fans, but what it boils down to in this case is that Everton have lost too much money in the past three seasons. English top-flight clubs are permitted to lose a maximum £105m over three years, and an independent commission supposedly found Everton’s losses through 2021-22 amounted to £124.5m. It is also rumored that Everton will be sued for hundreds of millions of pounds by other clubs that were relegated in the past two seasons. Everton is appealing the points deduction of course, but if it stands it will be a massive blow to their hopes of avoiding relegation this season. Everton were in 14th place and and 9 points clear of the drop before today, but now they find themselves in 19th place and 2 points away from safety. This is a huge, huge deal. I don’t recall the last time a team were given a points deduction from the FA in the middle of a season, and 10 points is the biggest deduction ever handed out to a club by the FA.

A couple of things on this, though. For one, FFP is a far from perfect set of rules and I think ten points is a harsh penalty to pay. If they were indeed in violation of the rules surrounding the clubs finances then fine, but how is this penalty supposed to help a cash-strapped club like Everton fix their finances? Relegation would be even more devastating to them financially. Is the FA trying to send a message to the club’s owners regarding spending? Perhaps, but taking away Premier League television revenue (should they be relegated) will not help Everton bring in more money to offset those losses. The punishment does not fit the crime, if you ask me.

Further, the application of FFP rules are not evenly applied to every club. Oil-rich Manchester City are also under investigation for (numerous!) violations of FFP, but the prospect of the reigning champions being given a points deduction seem rather slim. Why? Well, City are extremely well-funded and they have an army of lawyers working to slow down the adjudication of the charges they face. The source(s) of their funding have always been cloudy, though many suspect that the government of Kuwait funnels money into the club through sideways means. Football clubs under FFP are meant to be generally self-sustaining, but it seems that City is not really adhering to that policy. They make their own money to be sure, but the amount of money they bring in does not really match up with match day attendance revenue and sponsorship deals year after year. If the FA wants clubs to take FFP rules seriously, City need to face the same or worse punishment as Everton already has. If there is no such punishment forthcoming, clubs like City will continue to ignore FFP and their will be nothing “fair” about them. There’s no denying the rules must be tightened, but if they aren’t equitably applied then there’s no point in having them altogether.

Champions League Final: Manchester City Outlast Inter Milan to Win the European Cup and the Treble

The biggest match in club football each season was played earlier today at Ataturk Stadium in Istanbul, Turkey, and it featured English champions Manchester City versus Italian giants Internazionale Milan. All of the intrigue pre-match was focused on manager Pep Guardiola and City, as they had an opportunity to do something done only once before in English football – winning the Treble (Premier League, FA Cup, and CL/European Cup). City have come agonizingly close to winning Europe’s biggest competition in previous seasons, only to fall short in the final or semifinals. Inter and manager Simone Inzaghi for their part were looking to play spoiler and bring home their first European Cup since 2010. City were heavy favorites coming into the match given how well they have played this season, but there was a bit of a head-scratcher pre-match when Guardiola elected to tinker with his line-up and switch to a back-3 in defense instead of the usual back-4. Guardiola has a reputation for trying to out-think his opponents in final matches, and it has bitten him in the behind before.

It was warm and humid in Istanbul at kick off, and the teams spent the first few minutes feeling each other out. City winger Bernardo Silva had a good chance 8 minutes in when he dribbled into space in the box and lashed a shot wide of the far post. Inter’s defense solidified a bit after that, and City found it hard to create good chances. They didn’t get their next real opportunity until just past the 30 minute mark, when all-world striker Erling Haaland turned his defender and got a shot on goal. The angle was tight however, and Inter keeper André Onana was able to parry it away with his leg. Inter were getting the ball forward decently well themselves, but there was a lack of sharpness from them on the final pass. Too often they were shooting from distance instead of passing.

City were dealt a blow on 36 minutes when star midfielder Kevin de Bruyne was forced off through injury, and a lot of the action stopped too due to his substitution. It was unfortunate for him and a big loss for City, as there are times when de Bruyne is unplayable in the middle of the park. Was this their curse rearing it’s ugly head again? De Bruyne was replaced by midfielder/winger Phil Foden without further tactical adjustment from Guardiola. There weren’t many goal-mouth chances after that though, and it was 0-0 at halftime. Inzaghi was likely the happier of the two managers at the break, as his back-3 defenders Matteo Darmian, Francesco Acerbi, and Alessandro Bastoni had all done very well.

The second half started similar to the first – lots of possession in midfield for both sides but few chances created. Inter striker Lautaro Martinez was put through on goal by a wayward City back-pass, but City keeper Ederson was able to cover and clear the danger. City began another push for a goal shortly after that error though, and they were rewarded for their endeavors on 68 minutes. Center back Manuel Akanji brought the ball towards the edge of the box before slipping a pass through to Silva, although the angle of the ball took him wide to the right of the goal. He hit a cut-back cross towards the middle, but it hit an Inter defender and bounced into space inside the box. City’s defensive midfielder Rodri was on hand to pounce on it, and he side-footed a shot through the bodies in front of him. It was hit low and with a bit of power, and it settled neatly into the corner of the Inter net. Onana had no chance, and City celebrated wildly. The big Spaniard Rodri is not a goal-scorer normally, but he showed great technique with his finish from about 16 yards out.

Inter almost got an immediate response on 71 minutes when wingback Federico Dimarco saw his header hit the cross bar. It bounced right back to him after that, but his second attempt at a header was accidently blocked by substitute Inter striker Romelu Lukaku. Incredibly bad luck for the two of them there. Foden then almost sealed the trophy a few minutes after that with a lovely turn on the edge of the area that put him through on goal. His shot was a little rushed though and he didn’t get power or placement on it, and Onana was able to make a cat-like save down low. Milan then got another brilliant chance for an equalizer, only for the headed effort from Lukaku to be miraculously saved by Ederson from a scant five yards out. Replays showed that this was again nothing but dumb luck for City. Ederson completely missed the ball with his hands, but his left leg just so happened to be in the way and the ball went out for a corner. How it didn’t go in for Lukaku, I will never know.

Ederson was required to make one final save from a header after a corner deep into stoppage time, but that was the final action of the match. The whistle blew after 5+ minutes of stoppage time and City won their first European Cup in their history. They were probably the better team on the day, so from a pure footballing standpoint no one claim that they stole it or got outplayed. Congratulations to the individual players, particularly their English ones (Foden, winger Jack Grealish, and center back John Stones). The fact that they can lose a player like de Bruyne in the first half and not really miss him shows just how loaded with talent this team is.

But how did they accumulate all this talent? How did City assemble such a dominant roster? Well they have a ton of money for one, as they are owned by the government of Kuwait, a small but oil-rich nation in the Middle East. They have spent billions of pounds on this team, and the European Cup is the biggest reward possible for that investment. Many big clubs in England and across Europe have a ton of money though, so it’s not really their financial value I take issue with.

For me, there will always be an asterisk next to this trophy and every other trophy won by this current iteration of Manchester City. They are currently under investigation by the English FA and UEFA for 115 separate violations of the Financial Fair Play laws, meaning that it’s possible (even likely) they broke numerous rules on buying and paying their various players. No one dressed in sky blue will care about that today, but it is something worth considering for the neutral. The Premier League must punish City for these violations, otherwise it sends the message that whoever has the most money is going to win the big trophies. That might be fine for other sports, but such blatant rule violations from a nation-state backed club are an affront to the traditions of the game. However, City are just as good in the legal department as they are on the pitch. They have an army of lawyers that will fight these charges and allegations, and it’s possible that they may get away with committing these violations unpenalized. The various governing bodies of European football really need to look at their Financial Fair Play rules and actually enforce them with points deductions and the taking away of trophies if they want to prevent this sort of thing from happening. They can’t just fine a club and expect behavior to change. Issuing a fine to a club like City is laughable. They’ll just pay it and then carry on doing what they were doing!

So not a classic match in terms of drama, but still a decent game of football to end the season on. Inter fought until the bitter end. Credit to Guardiola and his players, but that is where the credit stops. And no matter how many Trebles City win, Manchester United will always be the first one to do it. We also did it without the backing of an oil state, and mostly with academy players!