Manchester United traveled to Türkiye last Wednesday for the penultimate match in their Champions League group stage campaign for a match against Galatasaray at Rams Park in Istanbul. It was a positively terrifying atmosphere, with the home support in full throat before, during, and after the match. Foreign clubs can and often do struggle in such a hostile atmosphere, which makes Turkish clubs very difficult to beat when they are at home. United needed 3 points to resuscitate a fairly dead European campaign, while Galatasaray also needed a victory to cement their claim on second place in the group.
The Red Devils got off to a flying start, getting two goals in the opening 20 minutes. Winger Alejandro Garnacho carried on his good form from the weekend and got the first with a high finish from close range, followed by midfielder Bruno Fernandes seven minutes later. Bruno picked up the ball on the left wing outside the box, then took a touch or two before unleashing a screamer of a shot from 20 yards out that Galatasaray keeper Fernando Muslera could do nothing about. The raucous crowd in Istanbul, while still loud, was the quietest it had been all evening.
The Cimbom were undeterred though. Bruno needlessly gave away a free kick in a dangerous area around the 28 minute mark, and United were punished for that recklessness by winger/forward Hakim Ziyech. He hit a low free-kick along the ground that went under the United wall and wrong-footed keeper Andre Onana. Well struck by Ziyech, but Onana likely should have done better to get down and make the save. It was 2-1 at the end of the first 45 minutes though, and United had done well to not concede another before halftime.
Midfielder Scott McTominay got a third goal for United on 55 minutes, and it was the result of well-executed build up from the back by United. After playing the ball through the middle of the pitch, winger Antony dos Santos found right back Aaron Wan-Bissaka on an overlapping run to his right. AWB delivered a beautiful cross into the box that fell right at the feet of the sliding McTominay. He turned the ball in from close range, and restored United’s two goal cushion. 3-1!
Again though, Galatasaray proved they have a great resilience about them. They won another free kick in a dangerous area just 7 minutes after the McTominay goal, similar to the position they had at the opposite end in the first half. Ziyech stepped up to take the free kick again, and he forced Onana to dive to his right to try and make the save. Unfortunately for Onana, the ball somehow ricocheted off his hand backwards and into the net. Ziyech wheeled away in celebration as Rams Park erupted, but this goal was down to Onana completely misjudging the shot and failing to keep it out. It was a pretty bad howler from him, and it continued United’s unfortunate trend of goalkeeping errors leading to opposition goals in the Champions League. More on Onana below.
The home side were galvanized by the mistake, and suddenly started playing with a lot more confidence. They got their equalizer on 71 minutes when winger Kerem Aktürkoğlu buried a fine shot past Onana from just inside the penalty area. He was found by an excellent pass over the top from Ziyech, with the United defense undone. United were guilty of poor marking on this goal, and they perhaps could have done more to stop the build-up from the back. But take nothing away from Ziyech and Aktürkoğlu. It was a goal of quality, and probably deserved from a neutral point of view.
The match ended 3-3, although many in Istanbul would have felt that Galatasaray were the better side and likely should have had a 4th if not for VAR overturning a penalty against United. The home side were particularly better in the second half. I hate to pin this result on one man because football is team sport, but Onana really let the side down in this match. There’s no getting around it. The first goal likely should have been saved, and the second one definitely should have been saved. The defense has really cost us in this group stage campaign. We have conceded 14 goals in these 5 matches, several of which were the fault of Onana. You can’t reasonably pin all the blame on him, but this was a guy that was touted for his ability to play in the Champions League. He was very good for Inter Milan in this tournament last year, helping them to reach the final. But for whatever reason this year, he has not done well. The defense doesn’t help him sometimes, but other times it’s very unclear what Onana is doing between the sticks. That said, he has been very good domestically this season. He is one of the better keepers in the Premier League, but for some reason his play drops significantly in Europe. Despite the bad match today, I still believe in Onana for a variety of reasons and I am sure he will improve.
The draw leaves United’s hopes for qualification to the knockout stages hanging by the proverbial thread. They are rock bottom of Group A on 4 points. They not only need to defeat Bayern Munich at Old Trafford in the final game, they then have to hope for a draw between FC Copenhagen and Galatasaray. Any other result in that match will see the Danish or Turkish side qualify in lieu of United. If United finish third in the group they would qualify for the Europa League, but I personally do not want us to have to participate in that tournament this year. The last thing we need would be more fixtures in far away countries that would most likely end up being meaningless. We need to either crash out completely in 4th, or hope that fortune favors us and we finish 2nd. The Premier League and FA Cup are way more important to me personally this year than the Europa League. My prediction for that final match day? United beats Bayern, but it ultimately doesn’t matter because Galatasaray is going to beat Copenhagen and clinch 2nd place. United will end up in the Europa League thanks to finishing 3rd, much to my would-be chagrin.
Taken as a one-off, this wasn’t a bad result. 3-3 in Istanbul is usually nothing to be ashamed of. But what bothers me the most about this match is that United blew a 2 goal lead twice! They were up 2-0 and then again at 3-1, and at this level of professional football that should be a victory. The good quality goal for Galatasaray to make it 3-3 never should have been anything more than a consolation goal. This team clearly still has issues with mental toughness and resiliency. There have been several occasions both in Europe and domestically where United have blown leads this season, and manager Erik ten Hag needs to sort that out immediately. To be fair, United have seen out their fair share of close victories this season as well, but they seem to crumble when resiliency is needed the most. This current iteration/generation of United players need to learn how to consistently win games, and that will only come with more time and practice at it. They do seem to be getting better about managing leads, but this match was a stark reminder that there is still a ways to go.
United face another difficult test in their next match, a trip to St. James’ Park to play Newcastle on December 2nd in the Prem. This will be a tough match, but also a great opportunity for United to build on their away win at Everton last weekend.
Glazers Out!